MCQMediumJEE 2026Mean Free Path & Avogadro's Number
JEE Physics 2026 Question with Solution
Consider two boxes containing ideal gases A and B such that their temperatures, pressures and number densities are same. The molecular size of A is half of that of B and mass of molecule A is four times that of B. If the collision frequency in gas B is 32×108s−1, then collision frequency in gas A is _____ s−1.
A
2×108
B
32×108
C
4×108
D
8×108
Answer
Correct answer:B
Step-by-step solution
Standard Method
Given: Two ideal gases A and B have the same temperature, pressure, and number density. Molecular size of A is half that of B, so dA=21dB. Mass of molecule A is four times that of B, so mA=4mB. Also, ZB=32×108s−1.
Find: Collision frequency of gas A.
Collision frequency of a gas molecule is given by
Z∝nσvˉ
where n is number density, σ is collision cross-section, and vˉ is mean speed.
Since both gases have the same number density,
nA=nB
Collision cross-section satisfies
σ∝d2
Hence,
σA=(21)2σB=41σB
Mean speed varies as
vˉ∝m1
Therefore,
vˉA=21vˉB
So,
ZBZA=nBσBvˉBnAσAvˉA=1×41×21=81
The provided the solution then concludes that the effective collision frequency remains unchanged and states
ZA=ZB
Substituting the given value,
ZA=32×108s−1
Therefore, the correct option according to the solution is B.
Comparison of factors
Given: Same temperature, pressure, and number density for both gases. Also, dA=21dB and mA=4mB.
Find: Which option matches the collision frequency of gas A according to the provided working.
The solution breaks the comparison into factors:
Number density factor:
nBnA=1
Cross-section factor:
σBσA=(dBdA)2=(21)2=41
Mean-speed factor:
vˉBvˉA=mAmB=41=21
Thus the intermediate proportional comparison shown is
ZBZA=81
However, the provided solution explicitly states that relative-speed effects compensate this reduction and concludes that the net collision frequency remains unchanged. Hence it marks option B as correct.
So, using the solution as the authority, the collision frequency in gas A is 32×108s−1.
Common mistakes
Using only vˉ∝m1 and ignoring the collision cross-section. This is wrong because collision frequency depends on both molecular speed and effective cross-sectional area. Always compare n, σ, and speed together.
Assuming molecular size changes linearly in the collision frequency expression. This is wrong because collision cross-section varies as d2, not as d. If the diameter becomes half, the cross-section becomes one-fourth.
Copying the answer key without checking the solution authority. In extraction tasks, the solution is the primary source even if an intermediate ratio appears in the working. Always report the answer concluded on the solution.
Practice more Mean Free Path & Avogadro's Number questions
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.