Given below are two statements: one is labelled as Assertion A and the other is labelled as Reason R. Assertion A: The kinetic energy needed to project a body of mass m from earth surface to infinity is 21mgR, where R is the radius of earth. Reason R: The maximum potential energy of a body is zero when it is projected to infinity from earth surface.
A
A False but R is true
B
Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
C
A is true but R is false
D
Both A and R are true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A
Answer
Correct answer:A
Step-by-step solution
Standard Method
Given: Assertion says the kinetic energy needed to project a body of mass m from the Earth's surface to infinity is 21mgR. Reason says the maximum potential energy of a body is zero at infinity.
Find: Which option correctly describes the truth of Assertion A and Reason R.
The gravitational potential energy at distance r from the centre of the Earth is
U=−rGMm
At infinity, gravitational potential energy becomes
U=0
The minimum kinetic energy required to take the body from the Earth's surface to infinity is the escape energy:
K=21mve2
where
ve=R2GM
Therefore,
K=RGMm
Using
g=R2GM
we get
GM=gR2
Hence,
K=RgR2m=mgR
So the required kinetic energy is mgR, not 21mgR. Therefore, Assertion A is false.
Now examine Reason R. Since gravitational potential energy is taken as zero at infinity, the statement that the maximum potential energy is zero at infinity is true.
Therefore, the correct conclusion is: Assertion A is false, but Reason R is true. The correct option is A.
Energy Interpretation
Given: A body starts from the Earth's surface and is projected to infinity.
Find: Whether the assertion value of kinetic energy is correct.
At the Earth's surface, the gravitational potential energy is
Us=−RGMm
At infinity,
U∞=0
So the increase in potential energy needed is
ΔU=U∞−Us=0−(−RGMm)=RGMm
For the body to just reach infinity with zero final speed, the initial kinetic energy must equal this increase in potential energy:
K=ΔU=RGMm=mgR
Thus the assertion value 21mgR is incorrect.
The reason is true because gravitational potential energy is indeed zero at infinity, but the assertion fails because the numerical value of the required kinetic energy has been written incorrectly.
Hence, Assertion A is false and Reason R is true, so the correct option is A.
Common mistakes
Using the orbital kinetic energy formula 21mgR in place of escape energy is incorrect. 21mgR is associated with satellite motion near the Earth's surface, whereas the energy needed to reach infinity is mgR. Always use escape energy for projection to infinity.
Assuming that potential energy being zero at infinity directly makes the required kinetic energy 0 is wrong. Zero potential energy at infinity is only the reference value. You must calculate the increase in potential energy from the Earth's surface to infinity.
Forgetting the relation g=R2GM leads to incorrect conversion of RGMm into terms of g and R. Substitute carefully to obtain RGMm=mgR.
Practice more Escape Velocity questions
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.