MCQMediumJEE 2023Probability Basics

JEE Mathematics 2023 Question with Solution

Let NN be the sum of the numbers appeared when two fair dice are rolled and let the probability that N2,3N,N+2N-2, \sqrt{3N}, N+2 are in geometric progression be k48\frac{k}{48}. Then the value of kk is:

  • A

    22

  • B

    44

  • C

    1616

  • D

    88

Answer

Correct answer:B

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: NN is the sum obtained on rolling two fair dice. The probability that N2,3N,N+2N-2, \sqrt{3N}, N+2 are in geometric progression is k48\frac{k}{48}.

Find: The value of kk.

For three numbers to be in geometric progression, the square of the middle term must equal the product of the other two terms.

(3N)2=(N2)(N+2)(\sqrt{3N})^2 = (N-2)(N+2)

So,

3N=N243N = N^2 - 4N23N4=0N^2 - 3N - 4 = 0(N4)(N+1)=0(N-4)(N+1) = 0

Hence,

N=4 or N=1N = 4 \text{ or } N = -1

Since NN is the sum of two dice, only N=4N=4 is possible.

The favorable outcomes are:

(1,3),(2,2),(3,1)(1,3), (2,2), (3,1)

So the number of favorable outcomes is 33.

The total number of outcomes when two fair dice are rolled is

6×6=366 \times 6 = 36

Therefore,

P=336=112P = \frac{3}{36} = \frac{1}{12}

Given that

k48=112\frac{k}{48} = \frac{1}{12}

we get

k=4k = 4

Therefore, the correct option is B.

Using GP condition and dice outcomes

Given: N2,3N,N+2N-2, \sqrt{3N}, N+2 are in geometric progression.

Find: The value of kk from the probability expression k48\frac{k}{48}.

Using the GP condition,

(middle term)2=(first term)×(third term)\text{(middle term)}^2 = \text{(first term)}\times\text{(third term)}

So,

(3N)2=(N2)(N+2)(\sqrt{3N})^2 = (N-2)(N+2)3N=N243N = N^2 - 4N23N4=0N^2 - 3N - 4 = 0

Factoring,

(N4)(N+1)=0(N-4)(N+1)=0

Thus N=4N=4 or N=1N=-1. Since the sum on two dice cannot be negative, reject N=1N=-1.

Now count the outcomes for sum 44:

  • 1+31+3
  • 2+22+2
  • 3+13+1

Hence favorable outcomes =3=3 and total outcomes =36=36.

P(A)=336=112P(A)=\frac{3}{36}=\frac{1}{12}

Comparing with k48\frac{k}{48},

k48=112\frac{k}{48}=\frac{1}{12}k=4k=4

So the required value is 44, hence the correct option is B.

Common mistakes

  • Using the wrong GP condition. For three terms in GP, the correct relation is b2=acb^2=ac, not 2b=a+c2b=a+c. The latter is for arithmetic progression. Use the square of the middle term equals product of the extremes.

  • Squaring 3N\sqrt{3N} incorrectly as 3N23N^2. Since 3N\sqrt{3N} is the square root of 3N3N, its square is 3N3N. This step is essential to form the correct quadratic equation.

  • Accepting N=1N=-1 as a valid value. Here NN is the sum of two dice, so NN must lie between 22 and 1212. Always check whether algebraic roots satisfy the context of the problem.

Practice more Probability Basics questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions