A student is given one compound among the following compounds that gives positive test with Tollen's reagent. The compound is:

- A
B
- B
A
- C
C
- D
D
A student is given one compound among the following compounds that gives positive test with Tollen's reagent. The compound is:

B
A
C
D
Correct answer:C
Standard Method
Given: One among compounds A, B, C, and D gives a positive test with Tollen's reagent.
Find: Which compound gives the positive Tollen's test.
Step 1: Understanding Tollen's reagent test. Tollen's reagent gives a positive test with aldehydes and compounds that can form aldehydes under the reaction conditions.
Step 2: Analysing the given compounds.
Step 3: Conclusion. Only compound C gives a positive Tollen's test.
Therefore, the correct option is C.
Functional Group Identification
Given: The compounds differ by whether they are acetals, hemiacetals, or alcohol-containing cyclic ethers.
Find: The compound that can respond to Tollen's reagent.
The key idea is that Tollen's reagent oxidizes aldehydes. A compound will also test positive if it can generate an aldehyde in the medium.
From the given structures, compound C is the hemiacetal, so it can generate an aldehyde and hence gives the positive Tollen's test.
Therefore, the correct option is C.
Mistake: Treating acetals and hemiacetals as chemically equivalent. Why it is wrong: acetals do not readily furnish aldehydes under Tollen's test conditions, whereas hemiacetals can exist in equilibrium with aldehydes. What to do instead: identify whether the carbon bears one and one group, which indicates a hemiacetal.
Mistake: Assuming any compound containing oxygen will respond to Tollen's reagent. Why it is wrong: the test is specific to aldehydes or compounds that generate aldehydes. What to do instead: check for aldehyde functionality or a functional group such as a hemiacetal that can convert into an aldehyde.
Mistake: Selecting the alcohol-containing structure D because alcohols are oxidizable. Why it is wrong: ordinary alcohols do not necessarily give Tollen's test; the reagent is not a general test for all oxidizable alcohols. What to do instead: focus on aldehyde-forming ability, not merely the presence of an group.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.