An organic compound (X) with molecular formula C3H6O is not readily oxidised. On reduction it gives C3H8O(Y) which reacts with HBr to give a bromide (Z) which is converted to Grignard reagent. This Grignard reagent on reaction with (X) followed by hydrolysis give 2,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol. Compounds (X), (Y) and (Z) respectively are:
A
CH3COCH3,CH3CH2CH2OH,CH3CH(Br)CH3
B
CH3COCH3,CH3CH(OH)CH3,CH3CH(Br)CH3
C
CH3CH2CHO,CH3CH2CH2OH,CH3CH2CH2Br
D
CH3CH2CHO,CH3CH=CH2,CH3CH(Br)CH3
Answer
Correct answer:B
Step-by-step solution
Standard Method
Given: Compound (X) has molecular formula C3H6O and is not readily oxidised. On reduction it gives compound (Y) with formula C3H8O. Compound (Y) reacts with HBr to give bromide (Z), which forms a Grignard reagent. This Grignard reagent reacts with (X) and after hydrolysis gives 2,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol.
Find: Compounds (X), (Y) and (Z).
A compound with formula C3H6O that is not readily oxidised is acetone (propanone), so
X=CH3COCH3
Ketones on reduction give secondary alcohols, therefore
CH3COCH3reductionCH3CH(OH)CH3
So,
Y=CH3CH(OH)CH3
Now (Y) reacts with HBr to form the corresponding alkyl bromide:
CH3CH(OH)CH3HBrCH3CH(Br)CH3
Hence,
Z=CH3CH(Br)CH3
This bromide forms the Grignard reagent, which reacts with acetone and on hydrolysis gives the tertiary alcohol 2,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol, confirming the choice.
Therefore, the correct option is B.
Step-by-step Identification
Compound (X) has formula C3H6O and is not readily oxidised, so it is taken as a ketone rather than an aldehyde.
Therefore, (X) is acetone:
CH3COCH3
Reduction of a ketone gives a secondary alcohol, so (Y) is isopropanol:
CH3CH(OH)CH3
Reaction of isopropanol with HBr gives 2-bromopropane, so (Z) is:
CH3CH(Br)CH3
The Grignard reagent formed from (Z) adds to acetone, and after hydrolysis produces 2,3-dimethylbutan-2-ol. This matches the required product.
Mistake: Choosing propanal for (X) only from the formula C3H6O. Why it is wrong: an aldehyde is readily oxidised, but the question says (X) is not readily oxidised. Do instead: identify (X) as the ketone acetone.
Mistake: Reducing acetone to 1-propanol. Why it is wrong: reduction of a ketone gives a secondary alcohol, not a primary alcohol. Do instead: write (Y) as CH3CH(OH)CH3.
Mistake: Forming the wrong bromide from (Y). Why it is wrong: substituting OH in isopropanol with Br gives 2-bromopropane, not 1-bromopropane. Do instead: convert CH3CH(OH)CH3 to CH3CH(Br)CH3.
Practice more Aldehydes & Ketones questions
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.