An ideal gas undergoes a cyclic transformation starting from point A and coming back to the same point by tracing the path A→B→C→D→A as shown in the three cases below. Choose the correct option regarding :

- A
- B
- C
- D
An ideal gas undergoes a cyclic transformation starting from point A and coming back to the same point by tracing the path A→B→C→D→A as shown in the three cases below. Choose the correct option regarding :

Correct answer:B
State Function in a Cyclic Process
Given: An ideal gas undergoes a cyclic transformation in each of the three cases and returns to the initial point A.
Find: The correct relation among for Case-I, Case-II, and Case-III.
For an ideal gas, internal energy depends only on the thermodynamic state, so it is a state function. In a cyclic process, the system returns to its initial state. Therefore, the initial and final states are the same.
Using the first law of thermodynamics,
but for a complete cycle, since the state returns to the starting point,
Hence, in all three cases,
Therefore, the correct option is B.
Why Path Does Not Matter
Given: Three different cyclic paths A→B→C→D→A are shown on the diagram.
Find: Whether differs from one case to another.
Concept used: For an ideal gas, internal energy depends only on temperature. Since temperature is determined by the state of the system, internal energy is a state function.
In a cyclic process, the gas starts from a point and returns to the same point after completing the cycle. So the initial and final temperatures are equal.
Therefore,
for each case separately.
Thus,
So,
Therefore, all three are equal and the correct option is B.
Assuming depends on the shape of the path on the diagram. This is wrong because internal energy is a state function. Use only the initial and final states to evaluate .
Confusing net work done in a cycle with change in internal energy. Work done can be non-zero for a cyclic process, but because the system returns to the same state.
Using and concluding that different values of or must give different . This is incorrect because in a cycle, and may both vary with path, yet their net difference over the full cycle is zero.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.