For a diatomic gas, if for rigid molecules and for another diatomic molecules, but also having vibrational modes. Then, which one of the following options is correct? (where and are specific heats of the gas at constant pressure and volume)
- A
- B
- C
- D
For a diatomic gas, if for rigid molecules and for another diatomic molecules, but also having vibrational modes. Then, which one of the following options is correct? (where and are specific heats of the gas at constant pressure and volume)
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: for a rigid diatomic molecule and for a diatomic molecule with vibrational modes.
Find: The correct relation between and .
For a gas,
So, as increases, the value of decreases.
For a rigid diatomic molecule, the degrees of freedom are . Hence,
Therefore,
When vibrational modes are active, additional degrees of freedom are included. Then,
and so
Therefore,
Now compare:
Thus,
Therefore, the correct option is D.
Conceptual Comparison
Given: A comparison of the specific heat ratios of two diatomic gases, one rigid and one with vibrational modes.
Find: Whether is greater than, equal to, or less than .
Vibrational modes add extra degrees of freedom to the molecule. Because of this, more heat supplied goes into internal energy storage for the same rise in temperature, which increases .
Since
a larger value of makes smaller.
So, for the diatomic gas having vibrational modes,
Hence, the correct option is D.
Assuming that adding vibrational modes increases . This is wrong because vibrational modes increase , and from , a larger gives a smaller .
Using the monoatomic value of degrees of freedom or the monoatomic heat-capacity ratio. This is incorrect because a diatomic rigid molecule has , not the monoatomic case.
Forgetting that each active vibrational mode contributes two degrees of freedom. This leads to an incorrect value of . Count both kinetic and potential contributions for vibration.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.