MCQEasyJEE 2024VSEPR Theory & Shapes of Molecules

JEE Chemistry 2024 Question with Solution

The molecule/ion with square pyramidal shape is:

  • A

    [Ni(CN)₆]²⁻

  • B

    PCl₅

  • C

    BrF₅

  • D

    PF₅

Answer

Correct answer:C

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: We need to identify which given molecule/ion has square pyramidal shape.

Find: The correct option.

From the solution, BrF5BrF_5 has 5 bond pairs and 1 lone pair on the central bromine atom.

Thus, the total number of electron regions is:

5+1=65 + 1 = 6

So, the electron pair geometry is octahedral.

Structure of BrF5 showing bromine at the center, five fluorine atoms around it, and one lone pair giving square pyramidal shape.

When one position of an octahedral arrangement is occupied by a lone pair, the molecular shape becomes square pyramidal.

Therefore, BrF5BrF_5 has square pyramidal shape, so the correct option is C.

Option-wise Elimination

Given: The options are [Ni(CN)6]2[Ni(CN)_6]^{2-}, PCl5PCl_5, BrF5BrF_5 and PF5PF_5.

Find: Which species has square pyramidal shape.

Using the extracted solution content:

  1. BrF5BrF_5 has bromine as the central atom with 5 bonded fluorine atoms and 1 lone pair.
  2. Hence its electron pair geometry is octahedral.
  3. Its molecular shape is therefore square pyramidal.

Also, the other listed species are not square pyramidal according to the solution discussion:

  • PCl5PCl_5 is trigonal bipyramidal.
  • PF5PF_5 is trigonal bipyramidal.
  • The nickel cyanide complex discussed in the solution is not square pyramidal.

Therefore, the only matching species is BrF5BrF_5.

So, the correct option is C, i.e. BrF5BrF_5.

Note: The solution contains a mismatch where it prints option B, but the worked explanation clearly identifies BrF5BrF_5, which is option C in the provided options.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing electron pair geometry with molecular shape. For BrF5BrF_5, the electron pair geometry is octahedral, but because one position is occupied by a lone pair, the molecular shape is square pyramidal. Always remove lone-pair positions when naming the molecular shape.

  • Assuming every molecule with five bonded atoms is trigonal bipyramidal. PCl5PCl_5 and PF5PF_5 have five bond pairs and no lone pair, so they are trigonal bipyramidal, but BrF5BrF_5 has an additional lone pair, which changes the shape.

  • Relying only on the printed option label from the solution. The solution text identifies BrF5BrF_5 as the correct species, so the answer must be matched to the actual option list, where BrF5BrF_5 is option C.

Practice more VSEPR Theory & Shapes of Molecules questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions