MCQMediumJEE 2023Electric Dipole

JEE Physics 2023 Question with Solution

A dipole comprises of two charged particles of identical magnitude qq and opposite in nature. The mass mm of the positive charged particle is half of the mass of the negative charged particle. The two charges are separated by a distance ll. If the dipole is placed in a uniform electric field EE, making a very small angle with the electric field, the angular frequency of the oscillations when released is given by:

  • A

    4qE3ml\frac{4qE}{3ml}

  • B

    8qEml\frac{8qE}{ml}

  • C

    8qE3ml\frac{8qE}{3ml}

  • D

    4qEml\frac{4qE}{ml}

Answer

Correct answer:A

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: A dipole has charges of magnitude qq separated by distance ll in a uniform electric field EE. The mass of the positive charge is mm and the mass of the negative charge is therefore 2m2m.

Find: The angular frequency of small oscillations.

Since the masses of the two charges are not equal, the dipole oscillates about its center of mass. So first we locate the center of mass and then compute the moment of inertia about it.

Let the distance of the center of mass from the negative charge be xx. Then the positive charge is at distance lxl-x from the center of mass. Using the center of mass condition,

2mx=m(lx)2m \cdot x = m \cdot (l-x) 2x=lx2x = l-x 3x=l3x = l x=l3x = \frac{l}{3}

So the center of mass is at a distance l3\frac{l}{3} from the negative charge and 2l3\frac{2l}{3} from the positive charge.

Now the moment of inertia about the center of mass is

I=2m(l3)2+m(2l3)2I = 2m\left(\frac{l}{3}\right)^2 + m\left(\frac{2l}{3}\right)^2 I=2ml29+4ml29I = \frac{2ml^2}{9} + \frac{4ml^2}{9} I=2ml23I = \frac{2ml^2}{3}

For a small angular displacement θ\theta, the restoring torque on the dipole is

τ=pEsinθpEθ\tau = -pE\sin\theta \approx -pE\theta

where the dipole moment is

p=qlp = ql

Hence,

τqlEθ\tau \approx -qlE\theta

Using rotational equation of motion,

Iθ¨=qlEθI\ddot{\theta} = -qlE\theta θ¨+qlEIθ=0\ddot{\theta} + \frac{qlE}{I}\theta = 0

Comparing with the standard form of simple harmonic motion,

θ¨+ω2θ=0\ddot{\theta} + \omega^2 \theta = 0

we get

ω2=qlEI\omega^2 = \frac{qlE}{I}

Substituting I=2ml23I = \frac{2ml^2}{3},

ω2=qlE2ml23=3qE2ml\omega^2 = \frac{qlE}{\frac{2ml^2}{3}} = \frac{3qE}{2ml}

so

ω=3qE2ml\omega = \sqrt{\frac{3qE}{2ml}}

The solution states the correct option is A. Therefore, based on the provided source, the correct option is A.

Using center of mass and rotational SHM

Given: Unequal masses are attached to charges +q+q and q-q, separated by ll, and the dipole is placed in a uniform electric field EE.

Find: The angular frequency for small oscillations.

The key idea is that translational motion and rotational motion decouple most naturally about the center of mass. Because the masses are unequal, taking moment of inertia about the midpoint would be incorrect.

The negative charge has mass 2m2m and the positive charge has mass mm. If the center of mass is measured from the negative charge, then

COM distance=ml+2m0m+2m=l3\text{COM distance} = \frac{m \cdot l + 2m \cdot 0}{m + 2m} = \frac{l}{3}

This agrees with the distances used above.

Then

I=2m(l3)2+m(2l3)2=2ml23I = 2m\left(\frac{l}{3}\right)^2 + m\left(\frac{2l}{3}\right)^2 = \frac{2ml^2}{3}

For small oscillations, the restoring torque magnitude is approximately pEθpE\theta with p=qlp=ql. Hence the rotational SHM equation becomes

Iθ¨+qlEθ=0I\ddot{\theta} + qlE\theta = 0

Therefore,

ω=qlEI=3qE2ml\omega = \sqrt{\frac{qlE}{I}} = \sqrt{\frac{3qE}{2ml}}

So the physically derived angular frequency is 3qE2ml\sqrt{\frac{3qE}{2ml}}, while the provided answer key marks A as correct. The recorded answer is therefore A to remain faithful to the source.

Common mistakes

  • Using the midpoint as the axis of oscillation is incorrect because the two masses are unequal. The dipole oscillates about its center of mass. Always find the center of mass first before computing moment of inertia.

  • Forgetting that the negative charged particle has mass 2m2m is incorrect. The statement says the mass mm of the positive charged particle is half of the mass of the negative charged particle, so the negative particle must have mass 2m2m.

  • Using the torque expression τ=qEθ\tau = qE\theta is incorrect because the restoring torque on a dipole in a uniform electric field is based on dipole moment, not charge alone. Use τ=pEsinθ\tau = -pE\sin\theta with p=qlp = ql.

Practice more Electric Dipole questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions