MCQMediumJEE 2023Aldehydes & Ketones

JEE Chemistry 2023 Question with Solution

Find out the major product from the following reaction:

Cyclohexenone ring with a ketone at the top, one double bond in the ring, and a methyl substituent on the lower right carbon; reagent arrow shows (1) MeMgBr/CuI and (2) nPrI.
  • A
    Option 1 shows a cyclohexene ring bearing a tertiary alcohol and methyl on the same top carbon, with another methyl substituent on the lower right carbon.
  • B
    Option 2 shows a cyclohexanone ring with a propyl substituent on the alpha carbon and two methyl groups attached to the lower right ring carbon.
  • C
    Option 3 shows a cyclohexanone ring with a propyl substituent on one alpha carbon and two methyl groups attached to the adjacent lower right ring carbon.
  • D
    Option 4 shows a cyclohexane ring without carbonyl, bearing a propyl and methyl on the top right carbon and two methyl groups on the lower right carbon.

Answer

Correct answer:C

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: The substrate is an α,β\alpha,\beta-unsaturated ketone treated with (1) MeMgBr/CuI(1)\ \text{MeMgBr/CuI} and then (2) nPrI(2)\ \text{nPrI}.

Find: The major product formed in the reaction.

The given reaction involves two steps.

  1. Reaction with MeMgBr/CuI\text{MeMgBr/CuI}: In the presence of CuI\text{CuI}, the Grignard reagent behaves as a softer nucleophile and gives 1,41,4-conjugate addition to the enone system rather than direct 1,21,2-addition to the carbonyl group.

  2. This places a methyl group at the β\beta-carbon and generates an enolate intermediate.

  3. Reaction with nPrI\text{nPrI}: The enolate is then alkylated at the α\alpha-carbon by nPrI\text{nPrI}.

So, the final product is the cyclohexanone retaining the carbonyl group, with propyl substitution at the α\alpha-position and gem-dimethyl substitution at the β\beta-position.

Therefore, the correct option is C.

Why conjugate addition dominates

Given: An enone reacts with MeMgBr/CuI\text{MeMgBr/CuI} followed by nPrI\text{nPrI}.

Find: Why the product corresponds to option C.

For an α,β\alpha,\beta-unsaturated ketone, a normal Grignard reagent often favors 1,21,2-addition. However, in the presence of CuI\text{CuI}, an organocuprate-like species is formed, and such reagents preferentially undergo 1,41,4-addition.

After 1,41,4-addition of Me\text{Me}, the double bond is saturated and an enolate is formed:

enoneCuIMeMgBrenolate after 1,4-addition\text{enone} \xrightarrow[\text{CuI}]{\text{MeMgBr}} \text{enolate after } 1,4\text{-addition}

This enolate then reacts with nPrI\text{nPrI} by α\alpha-alkylation, giving the ketone with a new propyl group next to the carbonyl.

Hence, the product must:

  • retain the carbonyl group,
  • have an additional methyl delivered to the β\beta-position, and
  • have a propyl group at the α\alpha-position.

Among the given structures, this matches option C.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming MeMgBr\text{MeMgBr} gives direct 1,21,2-addition to the carbonyl is incorrect here because CuI\text{CuI} changes the reactivity to favor 1,41,4-conjugate addition. Check the presence of copper salts before choosing the addition pattern.

  • Forgetting that the intermediate after conjugate addition is an enolate leads to the wrong second-step product. The enolate is trapped by nPrI\text{nPrI} through α\alpha-alkylation, so the propyl group appears next to the carbonyl.

  • Choosing an alcohol product is a common error because students confuse this with ordinary Grignard addition to ketones. In this reaction, the carbonyl is retained after conjugate addition and alkylation, so the final product is still a ketone.

Practice more Aldehydes & Ketones questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions