The correct statement among the following is:
- A
is diamagnetic and and are paramagnetic.
- B
and are diamagnetic and is paramagnetic.
- C
and are diamagnetic and is paramagnetic.
- D
and are diamagnetic and is paramagnetic.
The correct statement among the following is:
is diamagnetic and and are paramagnetic.
and are diamagnetic and is paramagnetic.
and are diamagnetic and is paramagnetic.
and are diamagnetic and is paramagnetic.
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: We must identify the correct magnetic behaviour of , and .
Find: Which option gives the correct diamagnetic or paramagnetic nature of these complexes.
Concept: Magnetic behaviour depends on oxidation state of the metal, nature of ligands, and geometry of the complex.
Step 1: Analyze
Oxidation state of is , so its configuration is . All electrons are paired.
Step 2: Analyze
Oxidation state of is , so it is . is a strong-field ligand and gives square planar geometry with low spin configuration. All electrons are paired.
Step 3: Analyze
Oxidation state of is , so it is . is a weak-field ligand and gives tetrahedral geometry with high spin configuration. Two unpaired electrons are present.
Therefore, and are diamagnetic, while is paramagnetic. The correct option is D.
Ligand Strength and Geometry View
Given: Strong-field ligands such as and favour electron pairing, while weak-field ligands such as favour unpaired electrons.
Find: Use ligand strength and geometry to identify the correct statement.
For , nickel is in oxidation state and has configuration , so no unpaired electron is present.
For , nickel is and the strong-field ligand produces a square planar low-spin complex, so electrons pair up and the complex is diamagnetic.
For , nickel is also but is weak field, giving a tetrahedral high-spin complex with unpaired electrons, so it is paramagnetic.
Hence the only correct statement is Option D.
Assuming all nickel complexes have the same magnetic behaviour is incorrect because ligand strength and geometry both matter. Check whether the complex is square planar or tetrahedral before deciding.
Treating as a strong-field ligand is wrong. is weak field, so it usually gives high-spin tetrahedral complexes with unpaired electrons.
Ignoring the oxidation state of nickel leads to wrong electron count. First find the oxidation state, then write the -electron configuration, and only after that decide pairing.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.