Two wires and made of different materials have lengths and , and areas of cross-sections and , respectively. They are stretched by the same magnitude under the same load. If the ratio of Young’s modulus of to that of is , find the value of .
- A
- B
- C
- D
Two wires and made of different materials have lengths and , and areas of cross-sections and , respectively. They are stretched by the same magnitude under the same load. If the ratio of Young’s modulus of to that of is , find the value of .
Correct answer:B
Standard Method
Given: Two wires and have lengths and , and cross-sectional areas and . The same load acts on both wires and the extension is the same.
Find: The value of if .
Young’s modulus is defined as:
For the same load and the same extension ,
Therefore,
Substituting the given values,
Given that
So,
the solution states option B, but the working shown gives , hence the defensible answer from the working is option A.
Using proportionality carefully
Given: Same load and same extension for both wires.
Find: Compare Young’s moduli using geometry.
From
when and are identical for both wires,
Hence,
Now substitute:
Dividing both terms by ,
So the ratio is . Comparing with gives .
Therefore, the correct value is , corresponding to option A.
Using instead of for same load and same extension. This reverses the ratio. Start from before comparing.
Comparing only lengths and ignoring cross-sectional areas. Both and appear in Young’s modulus, so omitting area gives an incorrect ratio.
Accepting the listed option without checking the algebra. The working shown gives , so the ratio must be matched carefully with .
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.