MCQEasyJEE 2026Young's Modulus, Bulk & Rigidity Modulus

JEE Physics 2026 Question with Solution

Two wires AA and BB made of different materials have lengths 6.0cm6.0 \, \text{cm} and 5.4cm5.4 \, \text{cm}, and areas of cross-sections 3.0×105m23.0\times10^{-5}\,m^2 and 4.5×105m24.5\times10^{-5}\,m^2, respectively. They are stretched by the same magnitude under the same load. If the ratio of Young’s modulus of AA to that of BB is x:3x:3, find the value of xx.

  • A

    55

  • B

    44

  • C

    22

  • D

    11

Answer

Correct answer:B

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: Two wires AA and BB have lengths LA=6.0cmL_A = 6.0 \, \text{cm} and LB=5.4cmL_B = 5.4 \, \text{cm}, and cross-sectional areas AA=3.0×105A_A = 3.0\times10^{-5} and AB=4.5×105A_B = 4.5\times10^{-5}. The same load acts on both wires and the extension is the same.

Find: The value of xx if YAYB=x3\frac{Y_A}{Y_B} = \frac{x}{3}.

Young’s modulus is defined as:

Y=StressStrain=FLAΔLY=\frac{\text{Stress}}{\text{Strain}}=\frac{FL}{A\Delta L}

For the same load FF and the same extension ΔL\Delta L,

YLAY \propto \frac{L}{A}

Therefore,

YAYB=LA/AALB/AB=LAABLBAA\frac{Y_A}{Y_B}=\frac{L_A/A_A}{L_B/A_B}=\frac{L_AA_B}{L_BA_A}

Substituting the given values,

YAYB=6.0×4.55.4×3.0=2716.2=53\frac{Y_A}{Y_B}=\frac{6.0\times4.5}{5.4\times3.0}=\frac{27}{16.2}=\frac{5}{3}

Given that

YAYB=x3\frac{Y_A}{Y_B}=\frac{x}{3}

So,

x=5x=5

the solution states option B, but the working shown gives YAYB=53\frac{Y_A}{Y_B}=\frac{5}{3}, hence the defensible answer from the working is option A.

Using proportionality carefully

Given: Same load and same extension for both wires.

Find: Compare Young’s moduli using geometry.

From

Y=FLAΔLY=\frac{FL}{A\Delta L}

when FF and ΔL\Delta L are identical for both wires,

YA:YB=LAAA:LBABY_A : Y_B = \frac{L_A}{A_A} : \frac{L_B}{A_B}

Hence,

YA:YB=LAAB:LBAAY_A : Y_B = L_AA_B : L_BA_A

Now substitute:

YA:YB=6.0×4.5:5.4×3.0=27:16.2Y_A : Y_B = 6.0\times4.5 : 5.4\times3.0 = 27 : 16.2

Dividing both terms by 5.45.4,

YA:YB=5:3Y_A : Y_B = 5 : 3

So the ratio is 5:35:3. Comparing with x:3x:3 gives x=5x=5.

Therefore, the correct value is 55, corresponding to option A.

Common mistakes

  • Using YALY \propto \frac{A}{L} instead of YLAY \propto \frac{L}{A} for same load and same extension. This reverses the ratio. Start from Y=FLAΔLY=\frac{FL}{A\Delta L} before comparing.

  • Comparing only lengths and ignoring cross-sectional areas. Both LL and AA appear in Young’s modulus, so omitting area gives an incorrect ratio.

  • Accepting the listed option without checking the algebra. The working shown gives YAYB=53\frac{Y_A}{Y_B}=\frac{5}{3}, so the ratio must be matched carefully with x:3x:3.

Practice more Young's Modulus, Bulk & Rigidity Modulus questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions