The magnitudes of power of a biconvex lens (refractive index 1.5) and that of a plano-convex lens (refractive index 1.7) are same.
If the curvature of the plano-convex lens exactly matches with the curvature of the back surface of the biconvex lens,
then the ratio of radii of curvature of the front and back surfaces of the biconvex lens is:
A
5:2
B
5:12
C
12:5
D
2:5
Answer
Correct answer:D
Step-by-step solution
Standard Method
Given: The magnitudes of powers of a biconvex lens and a plano-convex lens are equal. For the biconvex lens, refractive index is 1.5. For the plano-convex lens, refractive index is 1.7. The curved surface of the plano-convex lens has the same curvature as the back surface of the biconvex lens.
Find: The ratio of radii of curvature of the front and back surfaces of the biconvex lens.
Concept: The power of a thin lens in air is given by the lens-maker formula:
P=(n−1)(R11−R21)
For a plano-convex lens, one surface is plane, so its radius of curvature is infinite.
Step 1: Power of the plano-convex lens.
Let the curved surface radius be R. With refractive index n=1.7,
Pp=(1.7−1)(R1)=R0.7
Step 2: Power of the biconvex lens.
Let the front and back radii be R1 and R2. With refractive index n=1.5,
Pb=(1.5−1)(R11−R21)=21(R11−R21)
Step 3: Use the given condition. Since the curved surface of the plano-convex lens matches the back surface of the biconvex lens,
R=R2
Also, the magnitudes of powers are equal:
21(R11−R21)=R20.7
Step 4: Solve for the ratio as shown in the given working:
R21−R11=R21.4−R11=R20.4R1=25R2
Thus,
R1:R2=2:5
Therefore, the correct option is D.
Sign Convention Note
The key point is to apply the lens-maker formula with the correct sign convention for the radii. For the plano-convex lens, the plane surface contributes zero curvature because its radius is infinite. Then compare the magnitude of its power with that of the biconvex lens and substitute the condition R=R2. This leads to the required ratio, matching option D.
Common mistakes
Using the same refractive index for both lenses is incorrect because the biconvex lens has refractive index 1.5 and the plano-convex lens has refractive index 1.7. Use each value in its own lens-maker expression.
Treating the plane surface of the plano-convex lens as having a finite radius is wrong. A plane surface has radius of curvature infinite, so its contribution to power is zero.
Ignoring the sign convention for R1 and R2 can reverse the subtraction in the lens-maker formula. Write the formula carefully before equating magnitudes of powers.
Practice more Refraction & Lenses questions
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.