A bag contains balls out of which are red and are black, where . If three balls are drawn at random without replacement and all of them are found to be black, then the probability that the bag contains red and black balls is:
- A
- B
- C
- D
A bag contains balls out of which are red and are black, where . If three balls are drawn at random without replacement and all of them are found to be black, then the probability that the bag contains red and black balls is:
Correct answer:B
Standard Method
Given: A bag contains balls with red and black, where . Three balls are drawn without replacement and all are black.
Find: The posterior probability that the bag contains red and black balls.
Concept: This is a Bayes' theorem problem.
Let
and
Since no prior information is given, all values are equally likely, so
Number of black balls when there are red balls is . Therefore,
Now apply Bayes' theorem:
The upper limit is because for , fewer than black balls are available. Thus,
So,
Therefore, the required probability is , so the correct option is B.
Bayes Theorem Expansion
Given: The event observed is that all three drawn balls are black.
Find: .
Bayes' theorem gives
Since each possible value of from to is equally likely,
For a fixed , the probability that all three drawn balls are black is
Hence,
Substituting in Bayes' theorem, the common factor cancels, giving
Now evaluate:
and
Therefore,
Thus the correct option is B.
Assuming the required probability is only is incorrect. The question asks for a posterior probability after observing three black balls, so Bayes' theorem must be used. Compute , not just the likelihood of the observation.
Summing the denominator over all to without checking feasibility is wrong. If , then the bag has fewer than black balls, so drawing three black balls is impossible. Restrict the sum to through .
Forgetting the equal prior assumption leads to an incomplete setup. Since no prior information is given, all values of are taken equally likely, so for each admissible case before applying Bayes' theorem.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.