Statement I: The dipole moment of R–CN is greater than R–NC and R–NC can undergo hydrolysis under acidic medium to produce R–COOH.
Statement II: R–CN hydrolyses under acidic medium to produce a compound which on treatment with SOCl2, followed by the addition of NH3 gives another compound (X). This compound (X) on treatment with NaOCl/NaOH gives a product, that on treatment with CHCl3/KOH/Δ produces R–NC.
In the light of the above statements, choose the correct answer from the options given below.
A
Both Statement I and Statement II are true
B
Both Statement I and Statement II are false
C
Statement I is true but Statement II is false
D
Statement I is false but Statement II is true
Answer
Correct answer:D
Step-by-step solution
Standard Method
Given: Two statements about hydrolysis of R–CN and R–NC, and a reaction sequence involving SOCl2, NH3, NaOCl/NaOH and CHCl3/KOH/Δ.
Find: Which statement is true.
For Statement I, although the dipole moment of R–CN is greater than that of R–NC, the statement is incorrect in saying that R–NC undergoes acidic hydrolysis to form R–COOH. In reality, nitrilesR–CN undergo acidic hydrolysis to give carboxylic acids, whereas isocyanidesR–NC do not give R–COOH in this way. Therefore, Statement I is false.
The last step is the carbylamine reaction, so Statement II is true.
Therefore, Statement I is false and Statement II is true. The correct option is D.
Reaction Sequence Check
Given: A comparison of nitriles and isocyanides, and a multistep conversion starting from R–CN.
Find: Whether each statement is true or false.
Check the hydrolysis part first.
NitrileR–CN on acidic hydrolysis gives carboxylic acidR–COOH.
So the claim that R–NC gives R–COOH is incorrect.
Now verify the second statement step by step.
Acidic hydrolysis:
R–CN→R–COOH
Conversion of acid to acid chloride:
R–COOHSOCl2R–COCl
Reaction with ammonia to form amide:
R–COClNH3R–CONH2
Hofmann degradation:
R–CONH2NaOCl/NaOHR–NH2
Carbylamine reaction:
R–NH2CHCl3/KOH/ΔR–NC
Hence the full sequence is chemically valid, so Statement II is true.
Therefore, the correct option is D.
Common mistakes
Confusing nitrilesR–CN with isocyanidesR–NC. This is wrong because their connectivity and reactions are different. Check which atom of the –CN unit is attached to R before deciding the hydrolysis product.
Assuming that both R–CN and R–NC give R–COOH on acidic hydrolysis. This is wrong because the standard acidic hydrolysis to carboxylic acid applies to nitriles, not the isocyanide statement given here. Identify the functional group first, then apply the reaction.
Missing that R–CONH2 undergoes Hofmann degradation with NaOCl/NaOH to form R–NH2. Without this step, the final formation of R–NC cannot be justified. Track each intermediate carefully.
Forgetting that the reaction of a primary amine with CHCl3/KOH/Δ is the carbylamine reaction. This is wrong because that named reaction is the key step producing R–NC. Recognize the reagent pattern to identify the product.
Practice more Reaction Mechanisms (Substitution, Addition, Elimination) questions
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.