LIST-I (Complex/Species) LIST-II (Shape & magnetic moment)
A. [Ni(CO)4] I. Tetrahedral, 2.8BM
B. [Ni(CN)4]2− II. Square planar, 0BM
C. [NiCl4]2− III. Tetrahedral, 0BM
D. [MnBr4]2− IV. Tetrahedral, 5.9BM
Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
A
A-I, B-II, C-III, D-IV
B
A-III, B-II, C-I, D-IV
C
A-III, B-IV, C-II, D-I
D
A-IV, B-I, C-III, D-II
Answer
Correct answer:B
Step-by-step solution
Standard Method
Given: Match the complexes in LIST-I with their shape and magnetic moment in LIST-II.
Find: The correct correspondence and hence the correct option.
Strong field ligands such as CO and CN− cause pairing of electrons, while weak field ligands such as Cl− and Br− do not cause pairing. Also, magnetic moment is related to the number of unpaired electrons.
For [Ni(CO)4]: CO is a strong field ligand. This complex is tetrahedral and diamagnetic, so its magnetic moment is 0BM. Hence,
[Ni(CO)4]→III
For [Ni(CN)4]2−: CN− is a strong field ligand and causes pairing. The complex is square planar and diamagnetic, so
[Ni(CN)4]2−→II
For [NiCl4]2−: Cl− is a weak field ligand, so electrons remain unpaired. The complex is tetrahedral with magnetic moment 2.8BM. Hence,
[NiCl4]2−→I
For [MnBr4]2−: Br− is a weak field ligand. Mn2+ is d5 and remains high spin, giving a tetrahedral complex with magnetic moment 5.9BM. Hence,
[MnBr4]2−→IV
Therefore, the correct matching is
A−III,B−II,C−I,D−IV
So, the correct option is B.
Ligand Field Analysis
Given: The complexes [Ni(CO)4], [Ni(CN)4]2−, [NiCl4]2− and [MnBr4]2−.
Find: Their correct geometries and magnetic moments.
Strong field ligands: CO,CN−
Weak field ligands: Cl−,Br−
Magnetic moment formula:
μ=n(n+2)BM
where n is the number of unpaired electrons.
For [Ni(CO)4], nickel is in oxidation state 0 and the complex is tetrahedral with all electrons paired, so magnetic moment is 0BM.
For [Ni(CN)4]2−, the strong field ligand CN− gives a square planar arrangement with paired electrons, so magnetic moment is 0BM.
For [NiCl4]2−, the weak field ligand Cl− gives a tetrahedral high spin complex. With 2 unpaired electrons,
μ=2(2+2)=8≈2.8BM
So this matches I.
For [MnBr4]2−, manganese is Mn2+, that is d5. With weak field ligand Br−, it remains high spin with 5 unpaired electrons.
μ=5(5+2)=35≈5.9BM
So this matches IV.
Hence,
A−III,B−II,C−I,D−IV
Therefore, the correct option is B.
Common mistakes
Assuming all Ni complexes have the same geometry is incorrect because geometry depends on the ligand field strength and electronic configuration. Check whether the ligand is strong field or weak field before deciding between square planar and tetrahedral.
Confusing [Ni(CO)4] with a paramagnetic complex is wrong. CO is a strong field ligand and this complex is diamagnetic, so its magnetic moment is 0BM, not 2.8BM.
Assigning [NiCl4]2− as square planar is a common error. Since Cl− is a weak field ligand, the complex is tetrahedral with unpaired electrons. Use ligand strength before assigning shape.
Forgetting that Mn2+ is d5 and usually high spin with weak ligands leads to an incorrect magnetic moment. For [MnBr4]2−, do not force electron pairing; it corresponds to a high magnetic moment of about 5.9BM.
Practice more Crystal Field Theory questions
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.