Which one of the following complexes will have and B.M.?
- A
- B
- C
- D
Which one of the following complexes will have and B.M.?
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: We need the complex for which and B.M.
Find: Which option has the required magnetic moment and zero crystal field stabilization energy.
Use the spin-only formula:
where is the number of unpaired electrons.
A magnetic moment near B.M. corresponds to unpaired electrons because
which matches the required value closely.
Now examine the options:
: Here Fe is in the oxidation state, so it is . is a strong field ligand, so the complex is low spin with no unpaired electrons. Hence it does not satisfy the condition.
: Here Co is in the oxidation state, so it is also . gives a low-spin arrangement here, so there are no unpaired electrons. Hence it does not satisfy the condition.
: Here Fe is , so . is a weak field ligand, so the complex is high spin with unpaired electrons. Its magnetic moment is around B.M., not B.M.
: Here Mn is in the oxidation state, so it is . acts as a weak field ligand, giving a high-spin complex with unpaired electrons.
Also for high-spin , the crystal field stabilization energy is zero, so in the sense of zero CFSE.
Therefore, the correct option is D.
Option-wise Elimination
Given: The required complex must have zero CFSE and magnetic moment B.M.
Find: Eliminate all options except the one with high-spin configuration.
Hence
and high-spin has zero CFSE.
Therefore, the correct option is D, .
Note: The source options omit the minus signs in some complex charges, while the solution uses the conventional charged forms.
Confusing with zero octahedral splitting is incorrect. In this context the intended meaning is zero crystal field stabilization energy for a high-spin ion, not absence of splitting itself. Check whether the configuration gives zero CFSE.
Ignoring oxidation state before counting electrons leads to the wrong answer. First determine the metal oxidation state from ligand charges, then write the correct configuration.
Assuming every weak field complex with unpaired electrons will give B.M. is wrong. The value near B.M. specifically corresponds to unpaired electrons, so verify using .
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.