Two cylindrical vessels of equal cross-sectional area of contain water up to heights and , respectively. If the vessels are connected at their bottom, then the work done by the force of gravity is: (Density of water is and )
- A
- B
- C
- D
Two cylindrical vessels of equal cross-sectional area of contain water up to heights and , respectively. If the vessels are connected at their bottom, then the work done by the force of gravity is: (Density of water is and )
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: Two cylindrical vessels each have cross-sectional area . The initial water heights are and . The density of water is and acceleration due to gravity is .
Find: The work done by the force of gravity when the vessels are connected at the bottom.
When the vessels are connected, the water levels become equal. Using conservation of volume,
Since both vessels have the same area, the final common height satisfies
With ,
so
The work done by gravity equals the loss in gravitational potential energy.
For the water in the first vessel:
Its center of mass falls by
Hence,
For the water in the second vessel:
Its center of mass rises by
Hence,
Therefore, the net work done by gravity is
Thus, the work done by gravity is . The correct option is D.
Potential Energy Difference Method
Given: The two vessels have equal area with initial heights and .
Find: The work done by gravity.
Compute the initial potential energy directly using center of mass of each water column:
The total height after equalization is
so the final height in each vessel is
The final potential energy is
Hence the work done by gravity is the decrease in potential energy:
Substituting values,
Therefore, the work done by gravity is .
Using pressure difference formulas instead of energy conservation is incorrect here because the question asks for work done by gravity. First find the final common height by volume conservation, then evaluate the change in gravitational potential energy.
Taking the final height as or is wrong. The total volume is shared between two vessels of equal area, so the correct final height is obtained from , giving .
Using the full height change of the liquid columns instead of the center-of-mass shift gives an incorrect energy change. For a uniform liquid column, the center of mass is at half the height, so the relevant displacement is or , not directly.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step - free to start.