Which of the following phenomena cannot be explained by the wave theory of light?
- A
Reflection of light
- B
Diffraction of light
- C
Refraction of light
- D
Compton effect
Which of the following phenomena cannot be explained by the wave theory of light?
Reflection of light
Diffraction of light
Refraction of light
Compton effect
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: The options are Reflection of light, Diffraction of light, Refraction of light, and Compton effect.
Find: Which phenomenon cannot be explained by the wave theory of light.
The wave theory of light successfully explains phenomena such as:
However, the Compton effect involves the scattering of photons by electrons, which requires the particle nature of light and cannot be explained by the wave theory. It is explained using quantum mechanics.
Therefore, the correct option is D.
Concept-Based Explanation
Given: We are asked which of the given phenomena cannot be explained by the wave theory of light.
Find: The phenomenon that requires the particle nature of light.
Step 1: Recall phenomena explained by the wave theory. The wave theory of light explains:
These effects arise due to the wave nature of light, involving superposition and propagation of electromagnetic waves.
Step 2: Identify phenomena that require particle nature. Certain phenomena cannot be explained by wave theory and require the photon model of light. These include:
Step 3: Apply this to the given options. Among the listed options, only Compton effect requires treating light as photons scattering from electrons with transfer of energy and momentum.
Conclusion: Since the Compton effect cannot be described using the wave theory of light, the correct option is D.
Choosing Diffraction of light is incorrect because diffraction is one of the strongest signatures of the wave nature of light. Instead, remember that diffraction is explained directly by wave spreading and interference.
Confusing Compton effect with refraction or reflection is incorrect because Compton scattering involves photon-electron collisions and wavelength shift. Instead, identify it as a phenomenon requiring the particle model of light.
Thinking that all optical phenomena are explained by wave theory is incorrect because some effects, such as the Compton effect, need quantization of light. Instead, separate wave-based phenomena from quantum particle-based phenomena.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.