JEE Chemistry Question

Given: RBr [ (ii) H2O] (i) Mg, dry ether 2-methylbutane. Find: The maximum number of structural isomers of RBr that can produce 2-methylbutane by this sequence. Formation of a Grignard reagent from RBr gives RMgBr. On hydrolysis with water, the product is the corresponding hydrocarbon RH. Therefore, R in RBr must be the 2-methylbutyl skeleton. So we need all structural isomers of bromides having the carbon skeleton of 2-methylbutane that on replacement of Br by H give the same hydrocarbon. The distinct positions for bromine in 2-methylbutane are: 1. 1-Bromo-3-methylbutane 2. 1-Bromo-2-methylbutane 3. 2-Bromo-3-methylbutane The two terminal positions on one side are equivalent by symmetry, so they do not generate additional structural isomers. Hence, the maximum number of structural isomers of RBr is 3 Therefore, the correct option is A. The provided the solution contains two approaches. Approach Solution - 1 counts isomers of C4H9Br and concludes 4, which corresponds to a different question and is unrelated to the product 2-methylbutane shown in the image. Approach Solution - 2 matches the reaction shown in the image and correctly identifies the bromides that produce 2-methylbutane after Grignard formation and hydrolysis. Therefore, this approach is the relevant one for the present question. Since hydrolysis of RMgBr gives RH, all valid reactants must be structural isomers of bromopentane having the 2-methylbutane carbon framework. Counting distinct bromine positions on that framework gives 3 isomers. Therefore, despite the conflicting first extracted approach, the correct answer from the relevant working is 3, so the correct option is A.

JEE Question — Solution | JEE Chemistry

MCQMediumJEE 2025Alkyl Halides

Reaction scheme showing RBr treated with magnesium in dry ether and then water to give 2-methylbutane, followed by asking the maximum number of RBr producing this product considering structural isomers only.

A
$3$
B
$5$
C
$4$
D
$6$

Answer

Correct answer:A

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: $RBr \xrightarrow[\text{(ii) } H_2O]{\text{(i) Mg, dry ether}}$ 2-methylbutane.

Find: The maximum number of structural isomers of $RBr$ that can produce 2-methylbutane by this sequence.

Formation of a Grignard reagent from $RBr$ gives $RMgBr$ . On hydrolysis with water, the product is the corresponding hydrocarbon $RH$ . Therefore, $R$ in $RBr$ must be the 2-methylbutyl skeleton.

So we need all structural isomers of bromides having the carbon skeleton of 2-methylbutane that on replacement of Br by H give the same hydrocarbon.

The distinct positions for bromine in 2-methylbutane are:

1-Bromo-3-methylbutane
1-Bromo-2-methylbutane
2-Bromo-3-methylbutane

The two terminal positions on one side are equivalent by symmetry, so they do not generate additional structural isomers.

Hence, the maximum number of structural isomers of $RBr$ is

3

Therefore, the correct option is A.

Resolving the discrepancy in the extracted solution

The provided the solution contains two approaches. Approach Solution - 1 counts isomers of $C_4H_9Br$ and concludes $4$ , which corresponds to a different question and is unrelated to the product 2-methylbutane shown in the image.

Approach Solution - 2 matches the reaction shown in the image and correctly identifies the bromides that produce 2-methylbutane after Grignard formation and hydrolysis. Therefore, this approach is the relevant one for the present question.

Since hydrolysis of $RMgBr$ gives $RH$ , all valid reactants must be structural isomers of bromopentane having the 2-methylbutane carbon framework. Counting distinct bromine positions on that framework gives $3$ isomers.

Therefore, despite the conflicting first extracted approach, the correct answer from the relevant working is $3$ , so the correct option is A.

Common mistakes

Counting all isomers of $C_4H_9Br$ is incorrect because the product 2-methylbutane has $5$ carbon atoms. Instead, first infer that $RBr$ must be a bromopentane isomer whose hydrolysis after Grignard formation gives the same $C_5$ skeleton.
Assuming every carbon in 2-methylbutane gives a different bromide overcounts isomers. Some positions are equivalent by symmetry, so only distinct substitution positions should be counted.
Forgetting the role of hydrolysis of the Grignard reagent leads to wrong products. In this sequence, $RBr \to RMgBr \to RH$ , so the hydrocarbon obtained directly reveals the alkyl group $R$ .

Practice more Alkyl Halides questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Start free trial More on Alkyl Halides

Answer

Step-by-step solution

Common mistakes

Practice more Alkyl Halides questions

Related questions