MCQMediumJEE 2024Coulomb's Law & Superposition Principle

JEE Physics 2024 Question with Solution

Two identical charged spheres are suspended by strings of equal lengths. The strings make an angle of 3737^\circ with each other. When suspended in a liquid of density 0.7g/cm30.7 \, \text{g/cm}^3, the angle remains the same. If the density of the material of the spheres is 1.4g/cm31.4 \, \text{g/cm}^3, the dielectric constant of the liquid is:

  • A

    11

  • B

    22

  • C

    33

  • D

    44

Answer

Correct answer:B

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: Two identical charged spheres are suspended symmetrically. The angle between the strings remains the same in air and in a liquid. Density of sphere material is ρs=1.4g/cm3\rho_s = 1.4 \, \text{g/cm}^3 and density of liquid is ρl=0.7g/cm3\rho_l = 0.7 \, \text{g/cm}^3.

Find: The dielectric constant KK of the liquid.

Let the angle each string makes with the vertical be θ\theta. Since the angle between the strings is 3737^\circ, the same θ\theta is maintained in both situations.

For equilibrium in air:

Tcosθ=mgT \cos\theta = mg Tsinθ=FeT \sin\theta = F_e

Dividing,

tanθ=Femg\tan\theta = \frac{F_e}{mg}

For equilibrium in the liquid, buoyancy reduces the effective weight and the electrostatic force becomes Fe/KF_e/K:

Tcosθ=mgFbT' \cos\theta = mg - F_b Tsinθ=FeKT' \sin\theta = \frac{F_e}{K}

So,

tanθ=Fe/KmgFb\tan\theta = \frac{F_e/K}{mg - F_b}

Since the angle remains the same, the two expressions for tanθ\tan\theta are equal:

Femg=Fe/KmgFb\frac{F_e}{mg} = \frac{F_e/K}{mg - F_b}

Cancelling FeF_e,

1mg=1K(mgFb)\frac{1}{mg} = \frac{1}{K(mg - F_b)}

Hence,

K=mgmgFbK = \frac{mg}{mg - F_b}

Now write weight and buoyant force in terms of densities:

mg=Vρsgmg = V\rho_s g Fb=VρlgF_b = V\rho_l g

Substituting,

K=VρsgVρsgVρlg=ρsρsρlK = \frac{V\rho_s g}{V\rho_s g - V\rho_l g} = \frac{\rho_s}{\rho_s - \rho_l}

Using the given values:

K=1.41.40.7=1.40.7=2K = \frac{1.4}{1.4 - 0.7} = \frac{1.4}{0.7} = 2

Therefore, the dielectric constant of the liquid is 22. The correct option is B.

Force Balance in Air and Liquid

Given: The angular separation does not change when the spheres are immersed in the liquid.

Find: The value of dielectric constant KK.

The unchanged angle means the ratio of horizontal force to vertical force remains unchanged.

In air:

electrostatic forceweight=Femg\frac{\text{electrostatic force}}{\text{weight}} = \frac{F_e}{mg}

In liquid:

electrostatic force in mediumapparent weight=Fe/KmgFb\frac{\text{electrostatic force in medium}}{\text{apparent weight}} = \frac{F_e/K}{mg - F_b}

Equating these because the angle is the same:

Femg=Fe/KmgFb\frac{F_e}{mg} = \frac{F_e/K}{mg - F_b} K=mgmgFbK = \frac{mg}{mg - F_b}

Now,

mg=Vρsg,Fb=Vρlgmg = V\rho_s g, \qquad F_b = V\rho_l g

Therefore,

K=VρsgV(ρsρl)g=ρsρsρlK = \frac{V\rho_s g}{V(\rho_s - \rho_l)g} = \frac{\rho_s}{\rho_s - \rho_l}

Substitute ρs=1.4g/cm3\rho_s = 1.4 \, \text{g/cm}^3 and ρl=0.7g/cm3\rho_l = 0.7 \, \text{g/cm}^3:

K=1.40.7=2K = \frac{1.4}{0.7} = 2

Hence, the correct option is B.

Common mistakes

  • Using the angle between the strings directly as the angle with the vertical. This is wrong because each sphere is symmetric about the vertical, so the force balance uses half of the included angle. Use the equilibrium ratio consistently for one sphere.

  • Ignoring buoyant force in the liquid. This is wrong because immersion changes the effective weight to mgFbmg - F_b. Always use apparent weight in the vertical equilibrium equation.

  • Forgetting that electrostatic force decreases in a dielectric medium. This is wrong because the force becomes Fe/KF_e/K in the liquid. Include both dielectric effect and buoyancy together.

Practice more Coulomb's Law & Superposition Principle questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions