Consider the following complex ions: P = Q = R = The correct order of the complex ions, according to their spin-only magnetic moment values (in B.M.), is:
- A
R < Q < P
- B
R < P < Q
- C
Q < R < P
- D
Q < P < R
Consider the following complex ions: P = Q = R = The correct order of the complex ions, according to their spin-only magnetic moment values (in B.M.), is:
R < Q < P
R < P < Q
Q < R < P
Q < P < R
Correct answer:C
Standard Method
Given: The complex ions are , , and .
Find: The correct increasing order of their spin-only magnetic moments.
The spin-only magnetic moment is given by
where is the number of unpaired electrons.
For : iron is in the oxidation state, so it is . Since is a weak field ligand, the complex is high spin and all electrons remain unpaired.
For : vanadium is in the oxidation state, so it is . Water is a weak field ligand, so there are unpaired electrons.
For : iron is in the oxidation state, so it is . Water is a weak field ligand, so the complex is high spin with unpaired electrons.
Therefore, the order of magnetic moments is .
The correct option is C.
Treating as a strong field ligand is incorrect here. In these octahedral complexes, usually gives high-spin configurations for and . First determine whether the ligand is weak or strong field before counting unpaired electrons.
Using the wrong oxidation state for the metal leads to an incorrect -electron count. Always calculate the oxidation state from the overall charge of the complex, then write the correct electronic configuration of the metal ion.
Comparing magnetic moments without counting unpaired electrons is risky. The formula depends on , the number of unpaired electrons, not directly on the atomic number. Find first, then use .
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.