Given: Four aromatic isomeric compounds P,Q,R,S are provided. P contains −OH, Q contains −CHO, and R,S are ketones.
Find: Which among statements A to E are correct.
Step 1: Test with 2,4-DNP
2,4-DNP gives a precipitate with aldehydes and ketones.
- Q: aldehyde ✓
- R: ketone ✓
- S: ketone ✓
- P: alcohol ✗
⇒Statement A is true.Step 2: Baeyer’s test
Baeyer’s test is given by compounds containing C=C or C≡C.
- P: phenolic compound, no alkene ✗
- Q: aldehyde, no alkene ✗
⇒Statement B is false.Step 3: Sooty flame test
Aromatic compounds generally burn with a sooty flame due to high carbon content.
Q and R are aromatic ⇒ sooty flame⇒Statement C is true.Step 4: Iodoform test
Iodoform test is given by methyl ketones (−COCH3) and ethanol.
Only compound S is a methyl ketone, not R.
⇒Statement D is false.Step 5: Tollens’ test
Tollens’ reagent gives a silver mirror with aldehydes.
Q is an aldehyde ⇒ positiveOthers are ketones or alcohols.
⇒Statement E is true.Therefore, the correct statements are A, C and E only. The correct option is D.