The fifth harmonic of a closed organ pipe is found to be in unison with the first harmonic of an open pipe. The ratio of lengths of closed pipe to that of the open pipe is . The value of is _____.
- A
- B
- C
- D
The fifth harmonic of a closed organ pipe is found to be in unison with the first harmonic of an open pipe. The ratio of lengths of closed pipe to that of the open pipe is . The value of is _____.
Correct answer:A
Standard Method
Given: The fifth harmonic of a closed organ pipe is in unison with the first harmonic of an open pipe.
Find: The value of if
where and are the lengths of the closed and open pipes respectively.
For a closed organ pipe, only odd harmonics are present, and the frequency of the -th harmonic is
So, for the fifth harmonic,
For an open organ pipe, the first harmonic frequency is
Since the two sounds are in unison, their frequencies are equal:
Cancelling and simplifying,
Comparing with the given ratio
we get
Therefore, the correct option is A.
Using the closed pipe formula as if all harmonics are allowed. A closed organ pipe supports only odd harmonics, so the fifth harmonic must be written with . Do not use the open-pipe pattern for the closed pipe.
Confusing the first harmonic of the open pipe with a higher mode. For an open pipe, the first harmonic is the fundamental frequency, so use . Do not write .
Equating lengths instead of frequencies. Unison means the two frequencies are equal, not the lengths. First set , then solve for the ratio of lengths.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.