MCQEasyJEE 2025Electric Field & Field Lines

JEE Physics 2025 Question with Solution

Electric charge is transferred to an irregular metallic disk as shown in the figure. If σ1\sigma_1, σ2\sigma_2, σ3\sigma_3, and σ4\sigma_4 are charge densities at given points, then choose the correct answer from the options given below:

Irregular metallic disk with pointed top and bottom. Points are marked on boundary as sigma1 at top tip, sigma3 at bottom tip, sigma2 on right curved side, and sigma4 on left curved side.List of statements labeled A to E comparing surface charge densities sigma1, sigma2, sigma3, and sigma4 at different points on the metallic disk.
  • A

    D and E Only

  • B

    A and C Only

  • C

    A, B, and C Only

  • D

    B and C Only

Answer

Correct answer:C

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: An irregular metallic disk has surface charge densities σ1,σ2,σ3,σ4\sigma_1, \sigma_2, \sigma_3, \sigma_4 at the marked points.

Find: Which listed statements about the relative magnitudes of these charge densities are correct.

For a conductor in electrostatic equilibrium, surface charge density is higher at points with smaller radius of curvature, that is, at sharper portions of the conductor. Relatively flatter portions have lower charge density.

From the figure:

  • σ1\sigma_1 is at a sharp tip, so it is high.
  • σ3\sigma_3 is also at a sharp point, but less sharp than the top tip, so it is lower than σ1\sigma_1.
  • σ2\sigma_2 and σ4\sigma_4 are at corresponding side points on smoother curved portions, so they are equal and lower.

Thus the relation that best matches the figure is

σ1>σ3>σ2=σ4\sigma_1 > \sigma_3 > \sigma_2 = \sigma_4

Now check the statements shown in the figure:

  • A: σ1>σ3;  σ2=σ4\sigma_1 > \sigma_3;\; \sigma_2 = \sigma_4 — true
  • B: σ1>σ2;  σ3>σ4\sigma_1 > \sigma_2;\; \sigma_3 > \sigma_4 — true
  • C: σ1>σ3>σ2=σ4\sigma_1 > \sigma_3 > \sigma_2 = \sigma_4 — true

Therefore, the correct option is C, that is, A, B, and C Only.

Curvature-Based Interpretation

Given: Charge is placed on an irregular metallic disk.

Find: The correct set of true comparisons among σ1,σ2,σ3,σ4\sigma_1, \sigma_2, \sigma_3, \sigma_4.

The key physical idea is that on a conductor, charges crowd more strongly near sharp projections. Hence sharper boundary points have greater surface charge density than smoother side regions.

Using that idea:

  1. The top point σ1\sigma_1 lies at the sharpest point, so it is the greatest.
  2. The bottom point σ3\sigma_3 is also pointed, so it is greater than side values.
  3. The side points σ2\sigma_2 and σ4\sigma_4 lie on similar smoother curved portions, so they are equal.

Hence

σ1>σ3>σ2=σ4\sigma_1 > \sigma_3 > \sigma_2 = \sigma_4

This immediately implies statement A is correct, statement B is correct, and statement C is also correct.

So the final choice is A, B, and C Only, which corresponds to option C.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming charge spreads uniformly over the conductor is incorrect because surface charge density on a conductor depends on local curvature. Use the sharpness of the boundary, not just the total shape, to compare densities.

  • Treating all edge points as equivalent is wrong. Even though σ1\sigma_1 and σ3\sigma_3 are both on pointed regions, the sharper point has larger charge density. Compare relative curvature carefully.

  • Ignoring left-right symmetry at the side points can lead to taking σ2σ4\sigma_2 \neq \sigma_4. Since these side locations are corresponding smoother points, they should be taken equal here.

Practice more Electric Field & Field Lines questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions