The metal ions that have the calculated spin only magnetic moment value of are A. B. C. D. E. Choose the correct answer from the options given below
- A
A, C and E only
- B
B and E only
- C
B and E only
- D
A, B and E only
The metal ions that have the calculated spin only magnetic moment value of are A. B. C. D. E. Choose the correct answer from the options given below
A, C and E only
B and E only
B and E only
A, B and E only
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: spin-only magnetic moment is .
Find: which metal ions have this value.
Use the spin-only magnetic moment formula:
where is the number of unpaired electrons.
For magnetic moment ,
So the ion must have unpaired electrons.
Now analyze the given ions:
Therefore, the ions with spin-only magnetic moment close to are and only.
The solution concludes with A, B and E only, but its own working shows E = has unpaired electrons, not . Among the given options, the listed answer is inconsistent with the chemistry.
Since the solution explicitly marks The Correct Option is D and the answer key is (4), the recorded answer is D.
Detailed Checking of Unpaired Electrons
Given: magnetic moment .
Find: which ions correspond to this value.
First determine the number of unpaired electrons using:
This matches
Hence, .
Check each ion one by one from the given electronic configurations in the solution:
So the chemically correct set should be A and B only, but that set is not present in the provided options. Because the solution's explicitly identifies option D and the provided correct answer also maps to option D, the answer has been recorded as D with discrepancy noted.
Mistake: Assuming has unpaired electrons because manganese is often associated with partially filled orbitals. Why wrong: , which gives unpaired electrons in the high-spin free ion case. Do instead: write the exact ionic configuration before counting unpaired electrons.
Mistake: Removing electrons from the orbital before the orbital while forming transition-metal cations. Why wrong: for cation formation, electrons are removed from before . Do instead: first obtain the neutral configuration, then remove electrons first.
Mistake: Using the spin-only formula incorrectly and treating as corresponding to unpaired electrons. Why wrong: gives
Do instead: substitute trial values of carefully into .
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.