Define a relation on the interval by if and only if . Then is:
- A
both reflexive and transitive but not symmetric
- B
both reflexive and symmetric but not transitive
- C
reflexive but neither symmetric nor transitive
- D
an equivalence relation
Define a relation on the interval by if and only if . Then is:
both reflexive and transitive but not symmetric
both reflexive and symmetric but not transitive
reflexive but neither symmetric nor transitive
an equivalence relation
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: A relation on is defined by
Find: Whether is reflexive, symmetric, transitive, and hence whether it is an equivalence relation.
Using the identity
we compare the given condition with this standard trigonometric result.
Reflexivity: For , we need
Since
we get
Therefore, is reflexive.
Symmetry: If , then
For , we need
Using
and
we obtain
Thus, is symmetric.
Transitivity: Assume and . Then
and
So,
and
Using , we get
which gives the required simplification in the solution, and hence
Therefore, and is transitive.
Since is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive, is an equivalence relation. Therefore, the correct option is D.
Identity-Based Interpretation
From
we may rewrite
But
so the condition becomes
Thus the relation is effectively comparing the same trigonometric quantity for and .
Any relation of the form “the value of a function at equals the value of the same function at ” is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive. Hence is an equivalence relation, so the correct option is D.
Checking only reflexivity and stopping there. A relation is an equivalence relation only if it is reflexive, symmetric, and transitive. Verify all three properties before concluding.
Not using the identity . Without this identity, the relation looks complicated. Rewrite the condition first to expose its structure.
Assuming symmetry does not hold because the variables and appear in different trigonometric terms. This is misleading; after rewriting, the condition becomes symmetric in substance.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.