MCQEasyJEE 2025VSEPR Theory & Shapes of Molecules

JEE Chemistry 2025 Question with Solution

The molecules having square pyramidal geometry are:

  • A

    BrF5\mathrm{BrF_5} & XeOF4\mathrm{XeOF_4}

  • B

    SbF5\mathrm{SbF_5} & XeOF4\mathrm{XeOF_4}

  • C

    BrF5\mathrm{BrF_5} & PCl5\mathrm{PCl_5}

  • D

    SbF5\mathrm{SbF_5} & PCl5\mathrm{PCl_5}

Answer

Correct answer:A

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: We need to identify which given molecules have square pyramidal geometry.

Find: The correct option containing only molecules with square pyramidal shape.

Using VSEPR theory, square pyramidal geometry corresponds to species of type AX5EAX_5E, that is, 5 bonding pairs and 1 lone pair on the central atom.

For BrF5\mathrm{BrF_5}:

Steric number=6\text{Steric number} = 6

There are 5 bond pairs and 1 lone pair on bromine, so its electron geometry is octahedral and its molecular geometry is square pyramidal.

For XeOF4\mathrm{XeOF_4}:

Steric number=6\text{Steric number} = 6

Xenon has one bond with oxygen, four bonds with fluorine, and one lone pair. Thus it also has 5 bonding regions and 1 lone pair, giving square pyramidal geometry.

For SbF5\mathrm{SbF_5}:

Steric number=5\text{Steric number} = 5

There are 5 bond pairs and no lone pair, so the geometry is trigonal bipyramidal, not square pyramidal.

For PCl5\mathrm{PCl_5}:

Steric number=5\text{Steric number} = 5

There are 5 bond pairs and no lone pair, so the geometry is again trigonal bipyramidal.

Therefore, the molecules having square pyramidal geometry are BrF5\mathrm{BrF_5} and XeOF4\mathrm{XeOF_4}.

The correct option is A.

Stepwise VSEPR Analysis

Given: The molecules listed are BrF5\mathrm{BrF_5}, XeOF4\mathrm{XeOF_4}, SbF5\mathrm{SbF_5}, and PCl5\mathrm{PCl_5}.

Find: Which of these show square pyramidal geometry.

  1. A square pyramidal molecule is generally of type AX5EAX_5E.
  2. This means the central atom must have:
  • 5 bonding pairs
  • 1 lone pair
  • total steric number =6= 6
  1. Steric number 66 gives octahedral electron-pair geometry.
  2. With one lone pair in an octahedral arrangement, the molecular shape becomes square pyramidal.

Now examine each molecule:

For BrF5\mathrm{BrF_5}:

  • Bromine has 7 valence electrons.
  • It forms 5 bonds with fluorine.
  • One lone pair remains.
  • So it is of type AX5EAX_5E. Hence, BrF5\mathrm{BrF_5} is square pyramidal.

For XeOF4\mathrm{XeOF_4}:

  • Xenon has 8 valence electrons.
  • It forms one bond with oxygen and four bonds with fluorine.
  • One lone pair remains on xenon.
  • Effective arrangement is again AX5EAX_5E with steric number 66. Hence, XeOF4\mathrm{XeOF_4} is square pyramidal.

For SbF5\mathrm{SbF_5}:

  • Antimony forms 5 bonds and has no lone pair.
  • Type is AX5AX_5. Hence, its geometry is trigonal bipyramidal.

For PCl5\mathrm{PCl_5}:

  • Phosphorus forms 5 bonds and has no lone pair.
  • Type is AX5AX_5. Hence, its geometry is trigonal bipyramidal.

So only BrF5\mathrm{BrF_5} and XeOF4\mathrm{XeOF_4} satisfy the condition.

Therefore, the correct option is A.

Common mistakes

  • A common mistake is to count only the number of attached atoms and ignore the lone pair on the central atom. This is wrong because molecular geometry in VSEPR depends on both bonding pairs and lone pairs. Always determine the full steric number before assigning the shape.

  • Students often classify SbF5\mathrm{SbF_5} and PCl5\mathrm{PCl_5} as square pyramidal because they have five surrounding atoms. This is incorrect because both are AX5AX_5 species with no lone pair, so their geometry is trigonal bipyramidal, not square pyramidal.

Practice more VSEPR Theory & Shapes of Molecules questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions