Which of the following oxidation reactions are carried out by both and in acidic medium? A. B. C. D. E. Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
- A
A, D and E Only
- B
A, B and C Only
- C
B, C and D Only
- D
C, D and E Only
Which of the following oxidation reactions are carried out by both and in acidic medium? A. B. C. D. E. Choose the correct answer from the options given below:
A, D and E Only
A, B and C Only
B, C and D Only
C, D and E Only
Correct answer:B
Standard Method
Given: The reactions to be checked are oxidation reactions in acidic medium for both and .
Find: Which listed reactions are carried out by both oxidizing agents.
Both and are strong oxidizing agents in acidic medium. We examine each reaction from the solution:
A. Both oxidizing agents can oxidize iodide to iodine.
B. Both oxidizing agents can oxidize sulfide to sulfur.
C. Both oxidizing agents can oxidize ferrous ion to ferric ion.
D. This is a stronger oxidation. The solution states that can do this, but does not carry out this oxidation completely in acidic medium.
E. The solution states this is not consistently carried out by both reagents under similar acidic conditions.
Therefore, the reactions common to both are A, B and C only.
The correct option is B.
Note: The answer key marks option , but the worked solution concludes A, B and C only. As per the solution, the answer is taken as B.
Reaction-wise Analysis
Given: Oxidation reactions involving and in acidic medium.
Find: The set of reactions performed by both reagents.
Step 1: Recall the oxidizing behaviour in acidic medium.
Both act as strong oxidizing agents.
Step 2: Check each transformation.
Step 3: Collect the common reactions. The common set is A, B, C.
Hence the final answer is A, B and C only, so the correct option is B.
Assuming that because both are strong oxidizing agents, they must carry out every oxidation to the same final product. This is wrong because oxidizing strength and reaction conditions decide the extent of oxidation. Check each conversion separately.
Treating and as equivalent oxidations. This is wrong because oxidation to iodate is much more extensive than oxidation to iodine. Distinguish partial and further oxidation.
Relying only on the answer key key without checking the worked solution. Here the provided answer key conflicts with the solution. Use the reaction analysis in the solution to identify the correct option.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step - free to start.