A solid sphere and a hollow sphere of the same mass and of the same radius are rolled on an inclined plane. Let the time taken to reach the bottom by the solid sphere and the hollow sphere be and , respectively, then:
- A
- B
- C
- D
A solid sphere and a hollow sphere of the same mass and of the same radius are rolled on an inclined plane. Let the time taken to reach the bottom by the solid sphere and the hollow sphere be and , respectively, then:
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: A solid sphere and a hollow sphere have the same mass and the same radius, and both roll down the same inclined plane.
Find: Compare the times and taken to reach the bottom.
For rolling motion, the acceleration depends on the moment of inertia. The object with smaller moment of inertia accelerates more and reaches the bottom sooner.
The relevant energy relation is
For a solid sphere,
For a hollow sphere,
Since
the solid sphere has smaller moment of inertia, so it accelerates faster on the incline and takes less time to reach the bottom.
Therefore, . The correct option is D.
Moment of Inertia Comparison
Given: A solid sphere and a hollow sphere of equal mass and radius are rolled on an inclined plane.
Find: Whether is greater than, equal to, or less than .
When an object rolls down an incline, its motion includes both translational and rotational kinetic energy. The total mechanical energy is written as
where is mass, is acceleration due to gravity, is height, is speed of the center of mass, is moment of inertia, and is angular velocity.
For the two bodies,
and
The body with the larger moment of inertia stores more of the gravitational energy in rotation, so less is available for translational acceleration. Hence it moves down the incline more slowly.
Because the hollow sphere has greater moment of inertia than the solid sphere, the solid sphere reaches the bottom first.
Thus, , so the correct option is D.
Assuming both spheres take the same time because they have the same mass and radius is incorrect. In rolling motion, the moment of inertia also matters. Compare and before deciding.
Ignoring rotational kinetic energy and treating the motion as pure sliding is wrong. The correct approach is to use rolling motion, where gravitational potential energy is divided into translational and rotational parts.
Thinking the hollow sphere reaches earlier because it is hollow is incorrect. A hollow sphere has larger moment of inertia for the same mass and radius, so it accelerates less and takes more time.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.