MCQMediumJEE 2024Applications of P&C

JEE Mathematics 2024 Question with Solution

If nn is the number of ways five different employees can sit into four indistinguishable offices where any office may have any number of persons including zero, then nn is equal to:

  • A

    4747

  • B

    5353

  • C

    5151

  • D

    4343

Answer

Correct answer:C

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: 55 different employees and 44 indistinguishable offices, with empty offices allowed.

Find: The number of ways, nn, to distribute the employees.

Since the offices are indistinguishable, we count partitions of 55 distinct employees into at most 44 non-empty unlabeled groups.

Using Stirling numbers of the second kind:

S(5,1)=1S(5,1) = 1 S(5,2)=15S(5,2) = 15 S(5,3)=25S(5,3) = 25 S(5,4)=10S(5,4) = 10

Therefore,

n=S(5,1)+S(5,2)+S(5,3)+S(5,4)n = S(5,1) + S(5,2) + S(5,3) + S(5,4) n=1+15+25+10=51n = 1 + 15 + 25 + 10 = 51

Alternatively, from the partition listing shown:

  • 5,0,0,05,0,0,0 gives 11 way
  • 4,1,0,04,1,0,0 gives 5!4!=5\frac{5!}{4!} = 5 ways
  • 3,2,0,03,2,0,0 gives 5!3!2!=10\frac{5!}{3!2!} = 10 ways
  • 2,2,1,02,2,1,0 gives 5!2!2!1!=15\frac{5!}{2!2!1!} = 15 ways
  • 2,1,1,12,1,1,1 gives 5!2!1!1!1!=10\frac{5!}{2!1!1!1!} = 10 ways
  • 3,1,1,03,1,1,0 gives 5!3!1!1!=10\frac{5!}{3!1!1!} = 10 ways

Adding these,

1+5+10+15+10+10=511 + 5 + 10 + 15 + 10 + 10 = 51

Therefore, the correct option is C.

Bell Number View

Given: 55 distinct employees and 44 indistinguishable offices.

Find: The value of nn.

The total number of partitions of 55 distinct elements is the Bell number B5B_5.

From the solution,

B5=S(5,1)+S(5,2)+S(5,3)+S(5,4)+S(5,5)B_5 = S(5,1)+S(5,2)+S(5,3)+S(5,4)+S(5,5) B5=1+15+25+10+1=52B_5 = 1+15+25+10+1 = 52

The case S(5,5)=1S(5,5)=1 corresponds to all 55 employees sitting separately, which would require 55 non-empty offices. That is not possible because only 44 offices are available.

So,

n=B5S(5,5)n = B_5 - S(5,5) n=521=51n = 52 - 1 = 51

Therefore, the number of ways is 5151, so the correct option is C.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the offices as distinguishable. That would count arrangements for labeled offices and greatly overcount the answer. Since the offices are indistinguishable, only unlabeled groupings of employees should be counted.

  • Using stars and bars. That method distributes identical objects into boxes, but here the employees are distinct. The correct approach is set partitioning or casewise counting by group sizes.

  • Including the partition into 55 singleton groups. That case needs 55 non-empty offices, which is impossible when only 44 offices are available. Count only partitions into at most 44 groups.

Practice more Applications of P&C questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions