The number of ways in which identical apples can be distributed among three children such that each child gets at least apples is:
- A
- B
- C
- D
The number of ways in which identical apples can be distributed among three children such that each child gets at least apples is:
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given: identical apples are to be distributed among children, and each child must get at least apples.
Find: The number of possible distributions.
Use the stars and bars method after satisfying the minimum condition for each child.
First, give apples to each child.
So the remaining apples are
Now let the additional apples received by the three children be . Then
where .
The number of non-negative integer solutions is
Now,
Therefore, the number of ways is . The correct option is D.
Equivalent Distribution View
Given: Each child must receive at least apples out of identical apples.
Find: Total valid distributions.
To ensure the condition is satisfied, reserve apples for each child at the start. This accounts for
apples in total.
The problem is reduced to distributing the remaining
identical apples among distinct children with no restriction.
For distribution of identical objects among distinct groups, the count is
Here,
So the required number is
Evaluating,
Hence, the required number of ways is .
Students often forget to first give apples to each child. That violates the at least condition. Always satisfy the minimum requirement first, then distribute the remaining apples.
A common error is using the stars and bars formula directly on apples as . This counts distributions where one or more children get fewer than apples. Reduce the problem to unrestricted apples first.
Some students use the wrong combination formula, such as instead of . For distributing identical items into groups, use , not any other choice.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.