A square piece of tin of side is to be made into a box without top by cutting a square from each corner and folding up the flaps to form a box. If the volume of the box is maximum, then its surface area (in ) is equal to:
- A
- B
- C
- D
A square piece of tin of side is to be made into a box without top by cutting a square from each corner and folding up the flaps to form a box. If the volume of the box is maximum, then its surface area (in ) is equal to:
Correct answer:C
Standard Method
Given: Let be the side length of the square cut from each corner of the square sheet.
Find: The surface area of the open box when its volume is maximum.
The dimensions of the open box are:
The volume is
To maximize the volume, differentiate:
Set :
Simplifying,
Factorizing,
So, or .
If , then the length and breadth become , which is not feasible. Therefore, .
Now the surface area of the open box without top is
Substituting ,
the solution concludes the final value is , but it also marks the correct option as C. Since the solution working is the primary source and the listed options do not contain at option C, this is a source discrepancy. The defensible option by value is A.
Why the feasible value is chosen
From the critical points and , only values with can form a box, because the base side must remain positive. Thus makes the base collapse to zero size, so it cannot give a valid box. Hence the maximum-volume box occurs at , and its surface area is .
Using the total surface area formula of a closed box is incorrect because the box has no top. Include only the base and four side faces.
Accepting as a valid critical point is wrong because it makes the base dimensions . Always check feasibility after solving .
Maximizing surface area instead of volume is a conceptual error. First maximize the volume to find , then compute the corresponding surface area.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.