NVAMediumJEE 2023VSEPR Theory & Shapes of Molecules

JEE Chemistry 2023 Question with Solution

The number of species having a square planar shape from the following is: XeF4F_4, SF4F_4, SiF4F_4, BrF4F_4^-, [Cu(NH3H_3)4_4]2+^{2+}, [FeCl4_4]2^{2-}, [PtCl4_4]2^{2-}

Answer

Correct answer:4

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: The species are XeF4F_4, SF4F_4, SiF4F_4, BrF4F_4^-, [Cu(NH3H_3)4_4]2+^{2+}, [FeCl4_4]2^{2-}, and [PtCl4_4]2^{2-}.

Find: The number of species having square planar shape.

Use VSEPR theory for molecular species and standard coordination geometry for complexes.

  • XeF4F_4: square planar, type AX4E2AX_4E_2
  • SF4F_4: seesaw, not square planar
  • SiF4F_4: tetrahedral, not square planar
  • BrF4F_4^-: square planar, type AX4E2AX_4E_2
  • [Cu(NH3H_3)4_4]2+^{2+}: square planar
  • [FeCl4_4]2^{2-}: tetrahedral, not square planar
  • [PtCl4_4]2^{2-}: square planar

Therefore, the square planar species are XeF4F_4, BrF4F_4^-, [Cu(NH3H_3)4_4]2+^{2+}, and [PtCl4_4]2^{2-}.

Hence, the number of such species is 44.

Why the scraped solution is inconsistent

The solution discusses a different question about square pyramidal species such as PF5F_5, IF5F_5, BrF5F_5, and XeOF4F_4. That list does not match the given question.

Since the question asks about square planar species among XeF4F_4, SF4F_4, SiF4F_4, BrF4F_4^-, [Cu(NH3H_3)4_4]2+^{2+}, [FeCl4_4]2^{2-}, and [PtCl4_4]2^{2-}, the correct evaluation must be based on the question text and the correct answer field.

Thus, the valid count is 44.

Common mistakes

  • Counting SF4F_4 as square planar is incorrect because its electron-pair arrangement gives a seesaw shape, not a square planar one. Check both bonded pairs and lone pairs before assigning geometry.

  • Treating [FeCl4_4]2^{2-} as square planar is wrong because this complex is typically tetrahedral. For coordination compounds, use known geometries of the metal ion and ligand set, not only simple VSEPR.

  • Ignoring that BrF4F_4^- and XeF4F_4 are both of type AX4E2AX_4E_2 leads to undercounting. Species with two lone pairs opposite each other can give a square planar molecular shape.

Practice more VSEPR Theory & Shapes of Molecules questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions