NVAMediumJEE 2023Doppler Effect

JEE Physics 2023 Question with Solution

A person driving a car at a constant speed of 15m/s15 \, \text{m/s} is approaching a vertical wall. The person notices a change of 40Hz40 \, \text{Hz} in the frequency of his car's horn upon reflection from the wall. The frequency of the horn is in Hz:

Answer

Correct answer:420

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: speed of the car vs=15m/sv_s = 15 \, \text{m/s}, speed of sound v=330m/sv = 330 \, \text{m/s}, change in frequency ff0=40Hzf - f_0 = 40 \, \text{Hz}.

Find: the frequency of the horn f0f_0.

For reflection from a stationary wall, the reflected sound heard by the driver undergoes Doppler shift twice. Using the relation shown in the solution:

f=f0(v+vsvvs)f = f_0\left(\frac{v+v_s}{v-v_s}\right)

Substitute the given values:

f=f0(330+1533015)=f0(345315)f = f_0\left(\frac{330+15}{330-15}\right) = f_0\left(\frac{345}{315}\right)

Now use the given change in frequency:

ff0=40f - f_0 = 40

So,

f0(345315)f0=40f_0\left(\frac{345}{315}\right) - f_0 = 40

Simplify:

f0(345315315)=40f_0\left(\frac{345-315}{315}\right) = 40 f0(30315)=40f_0\left(\frac{30}{315}\right) = 40

Hence,

f0=40×31530=420Hzf_0 = \frac{40 \times 315}{30} = 420 \, \text{Hz}

Therefore, the frequency of the horn is 420Hz420 \, \text{Hz}.

Two-Step Reflection Interpretation

Given: the source and the driver move toward the wall with speed 15m/s15 \, \text{m/s}, the wall is stationary, and the observed increase after reflection is 40Hz40 \, \text{Hz}.

Find: the original horn frequency f0f_0.

First, the wall acts as a stationary observer for the moving source. The frequency received at the wall is:

f=vvvsf0f' = \frac{v}{v-v_s}f_0

Then the reflected sound acts as if it comes from a stationary source at the wall, while the driver approaches it with speed vsv_s. So the frequency heard by the driver is:

f=v+vsvff'' = \frac{v+v_s}{v}f'

Combining both steps:

f=v+vsvvvvsf0=v+vsvvsf0f'' = \frac{v+v_s}{v}\cdot \frac{v}{v-v_s}f_0 = \frac{v+v_s}{v-v_s}f_0

The change in frequency is:

ff0=40f'' - f_0 = 40

Therefore,

(v+vsvvs1)f0=40\left(\frac{v+v_s}{v-v_s}-1\right)f_0 = 40

Now simplify the bracket:

v+vs(vvs)vvsf0=40\frac{v+v_s-(v-v_s)}{v-v_s}f_0 = 40 2vsvvsf0=40\frac{2v_s}{v-v_s}f_0 = 40

Substitute v=330m/sv = 330 \, \text{m/s} and vs=15m/sv_s = 15 \, \text{m/s}:

2×1533015f0=40\frac{2\times 15}{330-15}f_0 = 40 30315f0=40\frac{30}{315}f_0 = 40

So,

f0=40×31530=420Hzf_0 = 40\times \frac{315}{30} = 420 \, \text{Hz}

Thus, the horn frequency is 420Hz420 \, \text{Hz}.

Common mistakes

  • Using the single Doppler shift formula only once is incorrect because the sound is first received by the wall and then the reflected wave is heard again by the driver. Treat the reflection as a two-step Doppler process.

  • Taking the wall as a moving reflector is wrong here because the wall is stationary. Use the stationary wall condition and apply source-observer motion correctly on the two legs of travel.

  • Substituting 15m/s15 \, \text{m/s} as observer speed in one step and as source speed in another without understanding the setup can create sign errors. Keep the direction clear: the car is approaching the wall in both stages.

Practice more Doppler Effect questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step - free to start.

Related questions