Let a=5i^−j^−3k^ and b=i^+3j^+5k^ be two vectors. Then which one of the following statements is TRUE?
A
Projection of a on b is 3517 and the direction of the projection vector is the same as b.
B
Projection of a on b is 35−17 and the direction of the projection vector is opposite to b.
C
Projection of a on b is 3517 and the direction of the projection vector is opposite to b.
D
Projection of a on b is 35−17 and the direction of the projection vector is opposite to b.
Answer
Correct answer:B
Step-by-step solution
Standard Method
Given:a=5i^−j^−3k^ and b=i^+3j^+5k^.
Find: The scalar projection of a on b and the corresponding correct option.
The scalar projection of a on b is
∣b∣a⋅b
Now,
a⋅b=(5)(1)+(−1)(3)+(−3)(5)=5−3−15=−13
and
∣b∣=12+32+52=35
Therefore, the projection is
35−13
Since the value is negative, the projection vector is opposite in direction to b.
The solution explicitly states that the correct computed projection is 35−13, but no option matches this value and the answer key says Drop. Among the listed options, B is the most defensible because it has the correct negative sign and opposite direction, though the magnitude shown in the option is inconsistent with the working.
Therefore, the closest matching option is B.
Option Discrepancy Note
Given:a=5i^−j^−3k^ and b=i^+3j^+5k^.
Find: Whether any listed statement matches the actual projection.
From the working shown in the solution,
a⋅b=−13
so the scalar projection is
35−13
This means two things:
The projection is negative.
Its direction is opposite tob.
Hence, any correct option must contain a negative value and state opposite direction. The solution also says the question is marked as dropped because no option matches the computed value exactly.
Therefore, the options are inconsistent with the actual calculation, and B is chosen only as the nearest logical match.
Common mistakes
Using the vector projection formula instead of the scalar projection formula without checking what the options describe. Here the options give a signed scalar value and direction separately, so first compute ∣b∣a⋅b, not the full vector expression.
Making an error in the dot product sign. The middle and last terms are negative because (−1)(3) and (−3)(5) are both negative. Writing 5+3−15 or 5−3+15 changes the conclusion completely.
Ignoring the meaning of the negative sign in the projection. A negative scalar projection means the projection vector points opposite to b, not along b. Always interpret the sign geometrically after calculation.
Practice more Dot Product questions
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.