MCQMediumJEE 2023Electric Field & Field Lines

JEE Physics 2023 Question with Solution

A point charge of 10μC10 \, \mu C is placed at the origin. At what location on the X-axis should a point charge of 40μC40 \, \mu C be placed so that the net electric field is zero at x=2cmx = 2 \, \text{cm} on the X-axis ?

  • A

    x=6cmx = 6 \, \text{cm}

  • B

    x=4cmx = 4 \, \text{cm}

  • C

    x=8cmx = 8 \, \text{cm}

  • D

    x=4cmx = -4 \, \text{cm}

Answer

Correct answer:A

Step-by-step solution

Standard Method

Given: A charge 10μC10 \, \mu C is at the origin and the net electric field at point PP on the x-axis at x=2cmx = 2 \, \text{cm} is zero. Another charge 40μC40 \, \mu C is to be placed at x0x_0.

Find: The location x0x_0 of the 40μC40 \, \mu C charge.

Number line on x-axis showing 10 microcoulomb charge at origin, point P at 2 cm, and 40 microcoulomb charge at x0 to the right with marked distances.

For the net electric field at PP to be zero, the electric fields due to the two positive charges must be equal in magnitude and opposite in direction.

k×1022k×40(x02)2=0\frac{k \times 10}{2^2} - \frac{k \times 40}{(x_0 - 2)^2} = 0

So,

104=40(x02)2\frac{10}{4} = \frac{40}{(x_0 - 2)^2}14=4(x02)2\frac{1}{4} = \frac{4}{(x_0 - 2)^2}(x02)2=16(x_0 - 2)^2 = 16

From the figure and field direction requirement, the 40μC40 \, \mu C charge must be to the right of PP, hence

x02=4x_0 - 2 = 4x0=6cmx_0 = 6 \, \text{cm}

Therefore, the correct option is A and the required location is x=6cmx = 6 \, \text{cm}.

Why the charge must be on the right of the point

At x=2cmx = 2 \, \text{cm}, the field due to the 10μC10 \, \mu C charge at the origin points toward the positive x-direction because the source charge is positive.

To cancel this field, the field due to the 40μC40 \, \mu C charge at PP must point toward the negative x-direction. That happens only if the 40μC40 \, \mu C charge is placed to the right of PP.

Although solving

(x02)2=16(x_0 - 2)^2 = 16

gives x0=6cmx_0 = 6 \, \text{cm} or x0=2cmx_0 = -2 \, \text{cm}, only x0=6cmx_0 = 6 \, \text{cm} satisfies the required field direction. Also, the solution's marks option D while writing x=6cmx = 6 \, \text{cm}; this is a label mismatch in the source, and the correct mapped option here is A.

Common mistakes

  • Equating the fields without checking their directions. Electric field is a vector, so equal magnitudes alone are not sufficient. First identify on which side the second positive charge must be placed so that its field at PP opposes the field due to the charge at the origin.

  • Using the distance of the second charge from the origin as x0x_0 directly in Coulomb's law for point PP. The relevant distance is from the second charge to PP, which is (x02)cm(x_0 - 2) \, \text{cm}.

  • Taking only the algebraic result from (x02)2=16(x_0 - 2)^2 = 16 and accepting both positions. The square gives two mathematical roots, but only the root consistent with field cancellation on the x-axis is physically valid here.

Practice more Electric Field & Field Lines questions

Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.

Related questions