Let the function have a maxima for some value of and a minima for some value of . Then, the set of all values of is:
- A
- B
- C
- D
Let the function have a maxima for some value of and a minima for some value of . Then, the set of all values of is:
Correct answer:D
Standard Method
Given:
Find: All values of such that the function has a maximum at some and a minimum at some .
For a cubic polynomial, extrema occur at the roots of . So we first differentiate:
For the function to have both a maximum and a minimum, must have two distinct real roots. Also, since the maximum is at some and the minimum is at some , the two critical points must lie on opposite sides of .
Using the product of roots of the quadratic equation
we get
For one root to be negative and the other positive, their product must be negative. Hence,
so
The solution also checks the discriminant condition for two distinct real roots:
Combining with the sign condition, the solution concludes
Therefore, the interval obtained from the working is .
The solution explicitly states The Correct Option is D, and also says the correct answer is option (4), even though the interval found in the working matches option C in the given options list. the correct option is D.
Sign of derivative at the origin
Given:
Find: The condition on for one critical point to lie at and the other at .
A quicker observation from the provided solution is to evaluate
If the two turning points lie on opposite sides of for an upward-opening quadratic , then must lie between its roots, so
Thus,
which gives
Hence the interval from the working is . The solution, however, marks the option as D despite this interval corresponding to option C in the listed choices.
Checking only that has real roots, but not ensuring that one root is negative and the other is positive. Two real roots alone do not guarantee a maximum at and a minimum at . Use the product of roots to force opposite signs.
Assuming the option label from the answer key must be correct without matching the interval obtained from the algebra. Here the working gives , so always compare the derived set with the listed options carefully.
Forgetting that extrema of a cubic are determined by the roots of , not by the roots of itself. First differentiate, then analyze the quadratic for the location of critical points.
Get unlimited AI-adaptive practice, mastery tracking, and an AI tutor that explains every step — free to start.